Firm Logo

Fines and Penalties for Shoplifting in NJ

June 21, 2021

The penalty for shoplifting in New Jersey is based on the value of the stolen item. If the stolen item is worth less than $200 it would be considered a disorderly persons offense. For this charge, the maximum fine an individual may face is $1,000, in addition to up to six months in jail. An item worth $200-500 is known as a fourth-degree charge. The fourth-degree charge means a $10,000 maximum fine and 18 months maximum jail sentence. A stolen item worth $500-75,000 will be a third degree charge with a maximum fine of $15,00 and maximum jail time of 5 years. For items worth more than $75,000, individuals may be facing the harshest of penalties: $150,000 in monetary fines and 10 years in jail.  


A prosecutor must build a strong case for shoplifting in New Jersey by using hard evidence. Some of that evidence may include video footage of the suspect approaching, selecting and concealing and carrying away the item. There may also be witnesses, including a merchant or a security guard,  who have observed the suspect. 


In order for a shoplifting charge, a prosecutor must prove intent. If someone accidentally walks out of a store with an item unknowingly, it would not be considered shoplifting. The five modes of shoplifting are purposely taking merchandise, concealment of merchandise, altering or transferring a price tag, transferring merchandise to another container, under-ringing of merchandise and transferring merchandise to another container. All of these modes include some sort of intent. If the evidence points to and intention of shoplifting than there will most likely be charges brought 

Civil Demand Letters

If the shoplifting incident happened at a large department store it is pretty likely that they will send a civil demand letter. The store is entitled the cost of the stolen item, any damage that occurred and a civil penalty. The letter is legal and will demand money from accused shoplifters. However, it is unwise to respond to any legal letter without first talking to an attorney. 

Fines and Penalty for Minors Caught Shoplifting 

The fines and penalties for shoplifting in NJ is different for an underage suspect. Firstly, cases of juvenile shoplifting are held in New Jersey’s family court system. Secondly, a minor charged with shoplifting may face time in a juvenile detention facility. A disorderly persons offence can mean up to 6 months in a detention facility. A fourth degree crime can lead to a year in prison. A third degree crime may lead to up to two years in a detention facility. Finally, a second degree crime equals up to 3 years in detention.

Legal Help 

The key takeaway to all of this information is that if you are accused of shoplifting in New Jersey, it is most important to have a skilled, knowledgeable, criminal defense attorney who may get your charge downgraded. 

Contact an Experienced Moorestown Criminal Defense Lawyer About Your Shoplifting Charges in Moorestown NJ

Were you arrested or charged with shoplifting in New Jersey? The consequences of a conviction could be severe, leaving you with a permanent criminal record and possibly even sending you to jail. That is why you need to speak with a qualified criminal defense attorney as soon as possible about your case. The Law Offices of Michele Finizio have successfully represented clients charged with shoplifting in Moorestown, Cherry Hill, Evesham Township, Burlington, and throughout New Jersey. Call (609) 230-0374 or fill out the online contact form to schedule a consultation with a member of our legal team. We have an office conveniently located at 9 E. Main St, Moorestown, NJ 08057, as well as offices located in Cherry Hill.

The articles on this blog are for informative purposes only and are no substitute for legal advice or an attorney-client relationship. If you are seeking legal advice, please contact our law firm directly.

Disorderly conduct consists of any improper behavior such as fighting, threats of violence, or creating a dangerous atmosphere.

Reviews Matter

“First class representation. Michele was my son’s attorney after he made a slight but bad decision that hurt no one, but one that potentially could have a caused a lifetime of employment problems in the future, despite having a four year college degree. First of all Michele was very proactive in protecting his rights. Rights we were not even aware of. She provided quick and reliable answers to our questions. Before we met with her our anxiety and worry was insatiable. The peace we felt after our first consultation alleviated all that and we knew we picked the right attorney. Her excellent negotiation skills resulted in a settling his case quickly and without conviction.

We owe a debt of gratitude for her service. I was shocked at how much she was able to do for my son. She is a solid lawyer who is honest and works to insure the best possible outcome for her client is achieved.”
- Former Client

“Michele was very prompt when getting back to me when I called regarding legal counsel. Michele kept me informed and in the loop while awaiting trial. Very professional qualities and I highly recommend Michele and will continue to seek her legal expertise in the future. Thanks.”
- Former Client

“I could not had ask for a better attorney. Michele Finizio treated my case and the case of those I’ve recommended as if we were part of her family. She gave it all she had, made her voice and case be heard in court and made it count, and we had the best possible outcome, thanks to her experience and expertise. Thank you very much for an outstanding job.”
- D.A.

"Michele is an outstanding, no “beating around the bush” lawyer. She has done a remarkable job as a lawyer for me. Before Michele, I did not get along with Criminal Lawyers – she comes HIGHLY recommended by me to anyone who needs a Criminal Lawyer."
- C.O.
View All Client Reviews